TEACHERS DISCUSSION FORUM
View Thread · Previous · Next Return to Index › Re: Whose English is it, anyway?
Jack Kanoi - 2004-07-10
In response to Re: Whose English is it, anyway? (Solomon Konneh)

> I think most schools in Japan and Korea and other places don't hire
> other nationals due to visa restrictions, since only a few nationals
> can get the work visa in these countries, but you'll also find other
> schools in Japan and Korea etc that reject other native speakers for
> various unknown reasons. I've met some black South Africans that
> couldnt get jobs in Korea.

> Even though the Chinese government issues visa to various nationals,
> some schools still reject other qualified English teachers for
> unknown reasons, maybe racist reasons or due to accents. The first
> question most schools ask if you call for a job is " where are u
> from? " a few will ask "are u black or white? " or
> "send your photo". They'll sometimes disqualify you just
> for these reasons regardless of your experiences or qualifications.

> I think the best approach is not to be bothered about discriminatory
> schools, if you apply and they turn u down for no good reasons, just
> forget about them and move on, If you're qualified with some
> experience, there'll always be some other schools that will hire for
> what u know or can do, not just where you're from or how you look.

> They claim that only native speakers can teach English, but since
> teaching is a skill that is learned, (no one is born a teacher) so
> its just silly to say only a few people can teach English. Some of
> those people do not or fail to acknowledge that therere even other
> English speaking countries. Of most TESL methodology books that I
> know, Ive not found in any that states only native speakers should
> teach English. Almost all these books stress that trained and
> qualified teachers should teach English whether they're native or
> non-native speakers

> The funny thing is, there are even some qualified non-native speakers
> that are teaching English in English -speaking countries like the US,
> Canada, Australia and so on, so its just nave if some countries
> insist on native speakers only.

You're right Solomon, but my question was less about me as I have had no serious problem on the score. The university where I have been teaching this past year wants me to continue but, being a writer with a fair bit of published work in China, I'd like to explore other cities in China and perhaps, other countries too...just so as to continue absorbing new ideas about and from diferent cultures and to write, if I can. That was what brought me to China in the first instance and that is what I'd like to continue doing. Since it's difficult to make a living on writing alone, especially if one wants to travel, I chose to teach. Fortunately, for me, wherever I have taught I have earned my keep and none of the schools I was at wanted me to discontinue there, offering each time to extend my contract.
The questions are more on account of an empirical interest and to induce some serious discussion.

Messages In This Thread
Whose English is it, anyway? -- Jack Kanoi -- 2004-07-10
Re: Whose English is it, anyway? -- Solomon Konneh -- 2004-07-10
Re: Whose English is it, anyway? -- Jack Kanoi -- 2004-07-10
Re: Whose English is it, anyway? -Mine, all mine! -- DoS -- 2004-07-10
Re: Whose English is it, anyway? -Mine, all mine! -- Anne Wang -- 2004-07-10
Re: Whose English is it, anyway? -Mine, all mine! -- DoS -- 2004-07-11
Re: Whose English is it, anyway? -Mine, all mine! -- Anne Wang -- 2004-07-11
Re: Whose English is it, anyway? -Mine, all mine! -- Jack Kanoi -- 2004-07-10
Re: Whose English is it, anyway? -Mine, all mine! -- Mike B -- 2004-07-11
Re: Whose English is it, anyway? -Mine, all mine! -- Dos -- 2004-07-12
Re: Whose English is it, anyway? -Mine, all mine! -- Mike B -- 2004-07-13
Re: Whose English is it, anyway? -Mine, all mine! -- boots43 -- 2004-07-12
Re: Whose English is it, anyway? -Mine, all mine! -- boots43 -- 2004-07-12
View Thread · Previous · Next Return to Index › Re: Whose English is it, anyway?





Go to another board -